Saxon Math vs Teaching Textbooks

Two of the most popular homeschool math programs, but they couldn't be more different. Saxon is the drill sergeant; Teaching Textbooks is the friendly tutor. Here's how to pick the right one for your kid.

Rigor Winner: Saxon Math

Saxon is significantly more rigorous. It covers more topics at each grade level and the constant spiral review ensures nothing gets forgotten. Teaching Textbooks is solid but won't push advanced students.

Independence Winner: Teaching Textbooks

Teaching Textbooks wins by a mile. The animated lessons teach the concepts, and auto-grading means your kid can work completely independently. Saxon requires more parent involvement, especially in lower grades.

Engagement Winner: Teaching Textbooks

The animated lessons and interactive format of Teaching Textbooks are far more engaging than Saxon's black-and-white worksheets. Kids consistently prefer TT.

Price Winner: Teaching Textbooks

Teaching Textbooks at $72/year per student is a better deal than Saxon's $60-120 per level, especially since TT includes instruction and grading.

College Prep Winner: Saxon Math

For serious college prep, especially in STEM fields, Saxon's rigor gives students a stronger foundation. Saxon students consistently score well on standardized tests.

Bottom Line

**Choose Saxon** if your kid needs to be pushed, you want maximum rigor, and you don't mind some tears along the way. **Choose Teaching Textbooks** if you want your kid to work independently, enjoy math, and you value your sanity. There's no wrong answer — just different priorities.